So, you’ve spent the day in Disney World and are watching the sunset from Disney’s BoardWalk.

After working up an appetite from walking around the parks all day, you decide to grab a bite to eat before calling it a night. Where do you go? There are some great places to check out in the area — Flying Fish offers up some impressive seafood, you can find a simpler meal and some delicious pastries at BoardWalk Deli, and soon, the whimsical Cake Bake Shop will be opening for brunch, lunch, and dinner. But, if you’re in the mood for some Italian fare, Trattoria al Forno fits the bill. They recently reopened after a short refurbishment, so I decided to stop by for dinner to check it out. Come see how it went!

Atmosphere

Trattoria al Forno sits on the BoardWalk, and if you time out your dinner right, you’ll have a beautiful sunset to watch while you wait for your table. When I arrived, the restaurant was already starting to get busy.

We’re having dinner at Trattoria al Forno! Come inside with us! pic.twitter.com/SajKbwwfEz

— Disney Food Blog (@DisneyFoodBlog) June 25, 2023

I checked in with the host and took a seat while I waited for a text telling me my table was ready.

Once it was time, I was led through the dining room — a warm space with dark wood, red accents, and gold light fixtures. During the renovation, the restaurant got new floors, which looked fresh and fit the decor.

Off to the side, an open kitchen gives you a glance at the magic in action.

In addition to this impressive kitchen, you’ll see the pizza oven, adorned with wooden pizza trays and open for the chefs to pass the pies out to servers.

Let’s take a look at the menu!

Menu

Once seated, I was given two menus. First, the wine list:

This featured a ton of options of rare wines by the glass and by the bottle.

There was also a page describing what the different classifications of wines mean…

…as well as a map to describe the regions!

The second menu had the food and a few drink selections.

There were some craft cocktails…

…and a selection of beer, grappa, and non-alcoholics.

For appetizers, you’ll find options like Calamari, Tomato Bruschetta, and Coastal Mussels. For Main Courses, selections include the Truffle Gnocchi, Oak-grilled Strip Steak Florentine, and the Veal Osso Buco.

From the brick oven, there is a selection of pizzas, like the Pizze Margherita, Pizze Pepperoni, and Pizze Carni. As a side, you can order Polpette, Garlic Bread, Crispy Pancetta Arancini, Shrimp Scampi, or Olives.

Don’t forget to look at the dessert menu! You can decide between Tiramisu, Panna Cotta, House-made Gelato, and Affogato al Cafe.

Let’s dig in!

Eats

First, I was served complimentary bread service. Here, that means a wonderful house-made ciabatta served with a garlic and olive oil dip.

The bread was amazing. It was soft with a beautiful crunch on the outside, and the oil on the side was a nice touch. The oil was rich and bold with a hint of a sweet balsamic vinegar to balance it out. The garlic was soft and a little sweet, but still had a little bit of a bite.

For an appetizer, I tried the Charcuterie Board for $15, which was a selection of Cured Meats, Cheeses, and Pickled Garden Vegetables, served with Ciabatta Bread.

For the cheeses, there was Fresh Mozzarella, Aged Provolone, and Herbed Ricotta. The mozzarella was soft and milky, with a delicate sweetness. It was topped with a bit of olive oil that balanced it nicely. The aged provolone was very unique! It was a harder cheese, a little salty, and with a bit of a bite. It reminded me a bit of Parmesan! The star, in my opinion, was the ricotta. It was fresh and creamy and a little sweet — I could have eaten a whole bowl of it, to be honest.

Mortadella, Prosciutto, Capocollo, and Calabrese were the meat options that day. All of them were extremely fresh and offered a unique addition to the plate. I particularly liked the prosciutto, which was shaved thin, had a beautiful marbling, and was delicate and salty. The chef wanted to create a nice balance of textures throughout the board, and I’d say very successfully carried that out.

On the side was the Giardiniera, a bright and fresh selection of pickled veggies that rounded out the dish. The celery was crunchy and light, and the peppers added a spicy kick. As a whole, this had a strong vinegary taste that brightened up the meats and cheeses.

For my entrees, I tried. the Lasagna al Forno and the Pizze Stagionale.

First, the Lasagna al Forno, for $30, was made with Blended Italian Cheeses, Beef, Veal, Pork, and Herbed Ricotta. I was surprised by its presentation! The pasta was rolled with the blend of meats and cheeses and then propped upright and topped with breadcrumbs.

While the look of this dish was unexpected, the flavors were incredible. The blend of beef, veal, and pork made the filling taste complex and tender. The pasta itself was perfectly al dente, and altogether it was a tasty combination of meat, cheese, and pasta — what’s not to like?

However, if you prefer a saucier lasagna, this one might leave you wanting more. The rolled-up noodles were sitting on a bed of béchamel and marinara, which was delicious, but I personally would have liked it to be more prevalent throughout the dish.

Lastly, I got the Pizza Stagionale for $23. This is a Chef’s Seasonal Pizza Selection that changes from time to time. For me, it was made with Arugula, Cipollini Onions, Mushrooms, Gorgonzola Cheese, and Balsamic Glaze.

This was delicious! The crust was the perfect texture — soft but with enough structure to hold all of the toppings. It tasted just like it was fresh out of a wood-burning pizza oven, with a slight char on the sides of the crust.

All of the toppings gave this pizza a ton of flavor. The cheese was rich and creamy, but sharp-tasting and a little salty. The balsamic and onions added a delicious sweetness to balance out the sharp cheese, and the arugula on top was fresh and a little nutty.

This was a great mix of sweet and savory that I really enjoyed, but it was pretty unique. The bold cheese combined with the mushrooms and sweet components won’t be for everyone. This was a surprisingly flavorful combination that I would get again.

For dessert, I ordered the Tiramisu for $10, which was Lady Fingers soaked with Espresso and layered with Italian Mascarpone Cream.

This was light and creamy — a perfect way to end a heavier meal, with a nice coffee flavor to give you a pick-me-up.

The lady fingers were soft and delicate, and the mascarpone was rich and thick but still fluffy.

To tie it all together, the touch of alcohol gave it a little kick.

Nosh or Not

Head on down to the BoardWalk and give Trattoria al Forno a try if…

• You love Italian food. We aren’t always impressed with the Italian food on property, but you can find some rather enjoyable meals here at Trattoria.
• You are staying at an EPCOT resort or want to enjoy the BoardWalk. The atmosphere on the BoardWalk is really something. It’s worth a stop on its own, but if you’re looking for a satisfying meal for your evening in the area, this is worth considering.
• You want to spend date night on the BoardWalk.

Skip Trattoria al Forno if…

• You want a quiet meal. This location can get loud and feel a little frenzied. This is a popular spot, and families with tired children seem to gravitate here.
• You are looking for something the whole family will enjoy. As noted, this isn’t a super enjoyable spot for a little one who has been in the parks all day. There isn’t really any Disney theming and the atmosphere feels a bit more grown-up.
• You are on a budget. This isn’t a cheap dining location, so if you’re hoping to save some money, you might want to look elsewhere.

Overall

Overall, this was a pretty good place to find some quality Italian food. It is a little pricey, but compared to other fine-dining restaurants in the area, it’s reasonable. The service I received was some of the best I’ve had in Disney World. My server, Andrea, was incredibly friendly and knowledgeable and made me feel right at home.

However, this place can get very busy, and it is not quiet. There were quite a few unhappy children here, and if you are looking for a quiet, romantic meal, that might throw a wrench in your plan. It is worth considering if you are a fan of Italian food, but keep in mind it can feel a little hectic in the dining room.

As always, stay tuned to DFB for all the latest Disney news and food reviews!

Click here to see the 5 most devestating menu changed in Disney World in 2023

What’s your favorite Italian food in Disney World? Let us know in the comments below!

The post REVIEW: The Italian Restaurant You May Have Totally Overlooked in Disney World first appeared on the disney food blog.