ALL The 2024 Magic Kingdom Halloween Treats at the Magic Kingdom — Reviewed and Rated

Halloween time has started and we reviewed all the new and returning 2024 Magic Kingdom Halloween treats for the season.

These items are available through October 31 during regular park hours and during the separately ticketed Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party, which also offers a host of exclusive treats.

2024 Magic Kingdom Halloween Treats

Main Street Bakery

WDW 2023 Halloween Magic Kingdom Main Street Bakery

*NEW* Minnie-shaped Cinnamon Roll – $7.49

Cinnamon Roll with green and purple icing and an orange bow

A Halloween-themed Mickey Mouse-shaped pastry on a colorful plate is held up in front of a decorative pumpkin lantern with Mickey Mouse’s face. People and trees are visible in the background.

This didn’t taste particularly fresh and was overall a fairly unremarkable take on the standard cinnamon roll. We know there are cinnamon roll devotees out there, but we think there are Halloween treats that are going to be a lot better use of your money at Magic Kingdom.

A Minnie-shaped Cinnamon Roll was available last year, but it had orange frosting and sprinkle-covered ears.

Rating out of 7: 3

Plaza Ice Cream Parlor

Plaza Ice Cream Parlor, with its red and white signage, showcases charming Halloween decor, including pumpkins on the roof. The building is adorned with orange fabric, and an American flag waves proudly in the background.

*NEW* Ice Cream Chocolate Cookie Sandwich – $7.49

 Halloween cookies with M&M’s Ghoul’s Mix Chocolate Candies and your choice of ice cream

A hand holding a dark-colored sandwich cookie with colorful candy pieces on top, against a background of a garden with red and pink plants.

The cookie looks great and will get you in the mood for the season. Once you get past the appearance, it’s just a basic ice cream cookie sandwich with M&M’s. It’s still a nice treat, and the creamy ice cream and sweet cookie complement each other well. It’s big enough to split, but you will have to hunt down a knife since Plaza Ice Cream Parlor only has spoons.

Rating out of 7: 5

The Plaza Restaurant

D5B87E60 DF7E 4DFF 89B0 90E0B46F8AE6

*NEW* Ghoulishly Gourmet Burger – $25

Two all-beef patties with pepper jack and Swiss cheese, candied bacon, balsamic-glazed mushrooms, onion ring, and truffle-buffalo aïoli served on a black bun

A gourmet burger with lettuce, melted cheese, bacon, and sauce in a dark bun, served with a side of fries on a plate.

The burger looks intimidating. It’s pretty big, which it should be since it costs $25. It comes with fries and pickles on the side. We were a little scared of the black bun because we’d read what happened when Burger King had the black Halloween Burger a few years ago and did not want to experience the same after-effects as many of the diners there.

However, the burger was cooked perfectly, and the blend of cheeses and the aïoli was delightful. Some people may be put off the the burger’s appearance or price, but overall, it was a really good burger.

Rating out of 7: 6

*NEW* Halloween Turkey Club – $19

Turkey club with bacon on black sandwich bread

A plate with a sandwich made with dark bread, layered with lettuce, tomato, and meat, next to a serving of thick-cut French fries. A lime wedge and a glass of dark soda are partially visible in the background.

This is a pretty basic club sandwich that just happens to come on dark brown bread. There is nothing about this sandwich that is particularly creative or noteworthy. It’s cheaper than the burger, but the quality of the meal is also significantly worse.

Rating out of 7: 3.5

*NEW* Layered Pumpkin Cake – $10

Pumpkin Cake with cream cheese mousse

A slice of cake on a black-rimmed plate, featuring green and purple icing, and two layers of white cream filling.

The flavor was sweet and the spice was a nice surprise. The cake looks great and is soft and moist, but it doesn’t hold its structure very well. It may have just felt a little too sweet to us because we’re not quite ready for pumpkin everything, but overall it was a pleasant new Halloween treat.

Rating out of 7: 5

*NEW* Graveyard Milkshake – $8.50

Chocolate milkshake with a dipped graveyard jelly doughnut, white chocolate tombstone, gummy candy, and a Haunted Mansion straw

A hand holding a chocolate milkshake topped with whipped cream, decorations, and a doughnut. The background shows a crowded, ornate café with people sitting at tables.

The graveyard milkshake is interesting to look at. The straw pierces directly through the heart of the jelly doughnut so lifting the straw reveals a blood-like jelly coating. Beneath that donut is a chocolate shake that has some Snickers pieces and M&M’s mixed in. Somehow this wasn’t overly sweet, which was great. The donut didn’t add to the flavor but it did pack a visual impact. It also didn’t help that our donut wasn’t particularly fresh.

Rating out of 7: 5.5

Casey’s Corner

A Victorian-style building with the sign "Casey's Corner" featuring a baseball motif, adorned in Halloween decor with autumn-themed bunting and pumpkins. The yellow structure has red accents and Coca-Cola signage, perfectly blending spooky charm with seasonal festivity.

*NEW* Chipotle Barbecue Pork and Street Corn French Fries – $7.79

French fries topped with fire-roasted corn, queso fresco, and cilantro

A hand holds a tray of loaded fries topped with corn, crumbled cheese, and vibrant seasonings over a green grassy area.

The chipotle barbecue pork is the same on all of the dishes served at this location. However, we felt that the fries were best suited for the pork because they’re easy to eat with a fork.

Rating out of 7: 4.5

*NEW* Chipotle Barbecue Pork and Street Corn Mini Corn Dogs – $10.79

Mini corn dogs topped with fire-roasted corn, queso fresco, and cilantro

A hand holds a tray of loaded food topped with shredded pork, corn, sauce, cheese, and various seasonings, with grass in the background.

The topping was properly portioned, even if there wasn’t much else to report from this item. Be prepared to eat with a fork and knife.

Rating out of 7: 4

*NEW* Chipotle Barbeque Pork and Street Corn Hot Dog – $14.79 (Regular) $15.79 (Footlong)

All-beef hot dog with fire-roasted corn, queso fresco, and cilantro

A hand holds a hot dog in a bun topped with corn, crumbled cheese, and a creamy sauce, over a grassy background.

This was very difficult to eat and not worth it. The pork doesn’t complement the all-beef hotdog at all. This was a mess.

Rating out of 7: 3

Churro Cart Near Cinderella Castle

*NEW* Worms ‘n Dirt Churro – $7.25

Churro rolled in cookies and cream dust and topped with marshmallow and sour gummy candy

A sign reads "Happy Halloween at Magic Kingdom" and features a photo of a churro rolled in cookies and cream dust, topped with marshmallow and sour gummy candy. The churro costs $7.25.

This churro is a disaster. It was stale, flavorless, and messy.  It was like eating cardboard if the cardboard industry figured out how to reduce the flavor of cardboard. The gummy worms are regular sour gummies and are by far the highlight of this otherwise inedible churro. Encourage your enemies to drop their hard-earned money on this. We threw our uneaten portion away, and the trash can spit it back out at us.

Rating out of 7: 1

Aloha Isle

A14E6EB9 F32C 4E0A 8031 96B06C28A442

*NEW* DOLE Whip Mango and Chamoy Float – $7.29

DOLE Whip Mango, pineapple juice, chamoy, and chili-lime seasoning

A hand holds a plastic cup with layered yellow and brown beverage topped with whipped cream and a red spice, with a pond, plants, and architectural background in sunlight.

The flavor of the mango ice cream is great, but the chamoy didn’t work, particularly at the bottom of the float. This wasn’t the worst item, but it probably would have been better if the mango and pineapple juice were left on their own. If you love chamoy, you will definitely like this item more than us.

Rating out of 7: 4

The Friar’s Nook

*NEW* S’mores Cup – $5.99

Layers of graham cracker crumbles, chocolate ganache, chocolate popping candies, milk chocolate panna cotta, and marshmallow cream

A hand with long nails painted purple holds a layered dessert in a clear cup, featuring chocolate, cream, and other layers, in front of a green leafy background.

Our marshmallow cream ghosts would not cooperate and kept falling down, but this is still a fun treat to look at. The snack is very simple, and it all works really well together. The chocolate pop rock candy doesn’t have the hardcore popping you remember as a child. It’s more subtle now and lingers longer making the treat very fun to eat. Overall, this was delicious.

Rating out of 7: 7

The Lunching Pad

lunching-pad-open-7-days-a-week-magic-kingdom-11092020-1132295

*NEW* Jalapeño Popper Dog – $14.79

 All-beef hot dog topped with sriracha cream cheese, crispy onions, bacon, and hades relish

Person holds a hot dog topped with orange sauce, relish, and crispy fried onions in a cardboard tray with greenery in the background.

Despite the steep price, this hot dog is absolutely worth eating. The Sriracha cream cheese instantly elevates this from a normal hot dog to something special. The crispy onions add great texture and the relish provides a nice backdrop. It’s definitely spicy, but not in an overpowering way. Overall, we were very pleased with this item.

Rating out of 7: 7

Cheshire Cafe

WDW MK Cheshire Cafe stock

Queen of Hearts Slushy – $6.29

Frozen cherry slushy drizzled with black cherry purée and topped with whipped cream and a crown-shaped chocolate piece

WDW MK 2023 Halloween Queen of Hearts Slushy 4

This is a delightful and refreshing cold drink. The cherry flavor is wonderful and the whipped cream topping is a nice touch. The crown doesn’t taste very good, but it’s a nice decoration. Other than the crown, this is a flawless slushy.

Rating out of 7: 7

Auntie Gravity’s Galactic Goodies

auntie gravitys

*NEW* Candy Corn Soft-Serve Sundae – $7.79

 Sweet corn soft-serve with butterscotch shell and candy corn

A hand holding a black bowl with orange and vanilla swirled soft serve ice cream, garnished with candy corn, white sprinkles, and orange drizzle, in an outdoor setting.

Our first instinct was to exclaim it was worthy of 14 ghosts, which you may notice is one higher than the 2001 horror film “13 Ghosts.” It’s that good. The hard shell and pieces of candy corn take this sundae to the next level. For those who hate candy corn, the pieces are easy to eat around. The flavor is more that of sweet corn than of the candy you remember. It’s smooth, sweet, and delicious. Easily the best Halloween treat available at Magic Kingdom.

Rating out of 7: 14!

*NEW* Sweet Corn Soft-Serve – $5.79

A hand holds a black bowl containing a swirl of soft-serve ice cream, with greenery and a white structure in the background.

The plain soft-serve version of this sweet corn ice cream is phenomenal. It’s just as good as the sundae, but it doesn’t have any of the tasty toppings.

Rating out of 7: 6

Witches Cold Brew – $5.29

Joffrey’s Coffee Cold Brew with pumpkin-spiced foam and sprinkles

A hand with manicured nails holds a plastic cup of iced coffee topped with whipped cream and chocolate shavings in an outdoor setting near water and greenery, reminiscent of the enchanting ambiance you'd find during Halloween at the Magic Kingdom.

The French vanilla coffee had a very bitter taste, and despite wanting to love this drink, we had to add creamer to stomach it. The candy pieces on top make it look festive, and the pumpkin spice foam was delicious, though too sparse. We tried to mix the foam to see if it would cut some of the bitterness, but no luck.

Rating out of 7: 2

For the latest Disney Parks news and info, follow WDW News Today on Twitter, Facebook, and Instagram.

The post ALL The 2024 Magic Kingdom Halloween Treats at the Magic Kingdom — Reviewed and Rated appeared first on WDW News Today.