We love Disney, but some of our hotel experiences have made us question our sanity.

You can plan the perfect trip, score the dining reservations, and even time your park days like a pro — but none of it matters if your hotel stay turns into a full-on disaster. Over the years, we’ve had a few downright awful experiences at Disney World resorts, and today we’re sharing five that we still haven’t recovered from. These are the stories that live rent-free in our heads anytime someone says “it’s worth the splurge” or “you should try it one more time.

The Grand Floridian

This one still stings. For one of our team members, they were celebrating their son’s birthday and decided to go all out at Disney’s flagship resort. When they opened the door to our room, the first thing that hit them was the smell, like wet dog that had been living in there for a week. The carpets were stained, the furniture was scuffed beyond repair, and there was an actual chunk missing from the headboard. They took pictures and went straight to guest services.

The response? “What do you want me to do about it? We’re booked full.” That came from the manager. They eventually “found” them another room, but it was hours later, well after they got back from the Magic Kingdom. They left milk and cookies as some sort of apology (because it was December), but the damage was done.

The same team member gave the resort one more chance on a short trip — a one-night stay. Big mistake. They didn’t get their room assignment until after the fireworks. That’s right. Nothing until almost 10PM. The Cast Members blamed them for not doing online check-in, even though they had. Three times. It “just didn’t take,” apparently. At this point, the Grand Floridian is permanently off their list.

Caribbean Beach: Beautiful, But Not Worth It

Caribbean Beach Resort has charm. The Skyliner access is great. The pool is gorgeous. But none of that helps when a Cast Member walks into your room without knocking while you’re bathing your kids.

This happened to one of our team members on check-out day. The kids wanted one last swim before we left, so they were getting ready in the room. It wasn’t even close to check-out time yet — they had at least an hour left. They’d put the “Do Not Disturb” sign on the door. Still, someone just walked right in while they were still bathing the kids. No knock. No warning. Just opened the door and came in. And that was the last time they stayed there.

All-Star Resorts During Cheer Season = No Sleep Ever

We get that Disney hosts a lot of events and competitions, and we don’t fault the cheerleaders for being excited. But if you’ve ever booked a stay at one of the All-Star Resorts during competition season, you already know where this is going.

There is yelling. The constant noise. Inside the rooms. Outside in the walkways. In the food court. At 6AM and 1AM. It doesn’t stop. We’ve had multiple stays where we got maybe three hours of sleep each night — and we’re not light sleepers. There’s just no peace and quiet when you’re surrounded by large groups of kids rehearsing routines in the hallways. Unless you’re there for the competition too, we’d suggest avoiding All-Stars during those weeks entirely.

Art of Animation: Where Are My Bags and My Bed?

Art of Animation is one of our favorite themed resorts, but one of our team members’ first stays there was rough. They checked in late one night, between 11PM and midnight. Since they’d requested a rollaway and had bags that needed to be delivered to the room, they figured they’d be able to settle in pretty quickly. That did not happen.

They waited. And waited. And waited some more. Their pajamas and bags didn’t show up until around 2:30AM. The rollaway? Same deal. That night turned into a long, grumpy mess. Granted, this was back in 2018, and we haven’t had issues at AoA since, but it was still one of those nights where we wished we’d just stayed off-property and saved ourselves the hassle.

The Bottom Line

We’ve stayed at a lot of Disney resorts over the years, and for the most part, things go smoothly. But when things go wrong, they can really go wrong. Whether it’s broken check-in systems, surprise walk-ins, noise at all hours, or rooms that feel like they haven’t been deep-cleaned since the Eisner era, some stays are just not worth the price. That’s why we always tell folks to research the timing of their stay, double-check everything at check-in, and speak up when something doesn’t feel right. And sometimes, it’s okay to say “never again” and stick to it.

Remember, the truth is that some of these things can happen at any hotel, even at Disney. We’ve also heard plenty of great experiences at each of the resorts we mentioned — these were just our personal worst-case scenarios. Your stay could be totally different (and hopefully much smoother).

Don’t want to go through all of the stress of booking your Disney World trip alone? Reach out to our friends at Small World Vacations! Their experienced agents monitor your reservation for possible future savings, compare discounts and figure out which one works best for your travel party, dates, resort, and touring plans. And, they share expert tips and first-hand advice with you about your magical vacation.

Keep following Disney Food Blog for all the latest from Disney!

The Best Hurricane-Ready Hotels in Disney World

Have you had a nightmare Disney resort stay? Let us know in the comments.

The post 5 Nightmare Hotel Stays We’ve Had in Disney World first appeared on the disney food blog.