REVIEW: Disney Turned Pumpkin Pie Into a Milkshake and We’re Not Sure How We Feel About It

REVIEW: Disney Turned Pumpkin Pie Into a Milkshake and We’re Not Sure How We Feel About It

EPCOT’s year-round barbecue spot — Regal Eagle Smokehouse — is serving up a couple of specialty items for this year’s EPCOT Food & Wine Festival!

Regal Eagle

The 2026 EPCOT Food & Wine Festival has officially opened, and it has a LOT to offer. There are plenty of food booths with tasty items, merchandise items to grab (of course), and even concerts to watch. But don’t let it overwhelm you, we’ve got you covered with everything you need to know. And now we’re heading to the Regal Eagle Smokehouse to check out some festival specials!

Click here to subscribe

Menu

You’ll find two Festival-specific items at Regal Eagle Smokehouse this year. First up is the new Blackberry Buckle. There is also a new Festival drink that sounds perfect for fall — Pumpkin Pie Milk Shake!

Menu 2026

Now that we’ve taken a look at the menu, let’s dive into the food itself!

Eats

This year you can order the new Blackberry Buckle with Blackberry Gelato and Streusel for $4.79.

Blackberry Buckle

Flavor-wise, we found this treat quite well-balanced. The blackberry and gelato melded well together, with no flavor being overpowering. The strusel was wonderfully crispy and stayed a really good texture even with the gelato on top of it, but the one part that isn’t great is that the very bottom of the treat is all blackberry, and it is so soggy because it is only blackberry. The cold treat was also really nice on a warm day, though it melted really fast. This may be because the tin it’s served in is heated — in fact, it was very hot to the touch — and the temperature of the cold gelato and the hot bowl led to quick melting and a mushy texture.

The Blackberry Buckle

Overall, fans of blackberries will likely really enjoy the flavors here. However, if you are someone who is sensitive to textures or you just really don’t like those mushy textures, you’re very likely to not be a fan.

Drinks

And just in time for all things PUMPKIN, you’ll find the new Pumpkin Pie Milk Shake made with Vanilla Ice Cream, Pumpkin Pie Filling, and Caramel Sauce topped with Whipped Cream and Streusel for $6.79.

Pumpkin Pie Milk Shake

This shake was exactly what the name implies! It actually tasted like the equivalent of sticking a straw right in the center of a piece of pumpkin pie and taking a sip. It’s definitely heavier on the spice rather than on the sweet side of pumpkin flavor.

Pumpkin Milk Shake

Suffice it to say, big fans of pumpkin pie will enjoy this immensely. However, those looking for a little bit more of a balanced pumpkin flavor might find it a bit too overpowering.

OVERALL

Overall, both of the dessert offerings at Regal Eagle are a bit of a mixed bag. Fans of blackberries or pumpkin pie will love these respective desserts, and likely want to go back for seconds. However, those with more general palates may find each of them too overpowering to really enjoy.

Full Spread

That’s it for this booth, but there’s a LOT more where that came from!

Click here to see FULL reviews of EVERY. SINGLE. BOOTH. at the Food & Wine Festival!

Trying to plan the PERFECT trip to the 2026 EPCOT Food & Wine Festival? We’ll be keeping you updated on all of the latest. Click our links below for the information you need to know:

And don’t forget to pick up our 2026 EPCOT Food & Wine Festival e-book! See more details about the book below.

IT’S WINE & DINE TIME!


Food & Wine Festival can be a bummer. You stand in line waiting for what looks like the perfect treat, and it’s a bust. But fear not, dear friends, we compiled EVERYTHING you need (and the things to avoid!) to plan the ULTIMATE EPCOT Food & Wine Festival experience.

If you’re planning a day or a week at the festival, we’ve got every performance, activity, and tasty nosh detailed out so you can make the most of your time and money. Listen, it’s a tough job eating and documenting the nearly 200 bites and sips, but we do it all for YOU!

Join the DFB Newsletter to get all the breaking news right in your inbox! Click here to Subscribe!

What items from this booth would you most want to try? Tell us in the comments!

Important Disney Dates Simplified – Get a list of all of your important dates for your upcoming Disney vacation so you don’t miss a thing.