REVIEW: This NEW Magic Kingdom Treat Is a Photo Op You Can Also Eat!

REVIEW: This NEW Magic Kingdom Treat Is a Photo Op You Can Also Eat!

Halloween has officially come to Disney World, and we couldn’t be more excited! Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party has officially kicked off, and with it comes a TON of new eats, drinks, merchandise, entertainment, and more at Magic Kingdom.

Headless Horseman Treat

There are over 50 spooky snacks at this year’s event, most of which are exclusive and only available during the party. Right now, we’re heading to Casey’s Corner to check out a new treat that’s only available during Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party, so come along with us!

Click here for a FREE Halloween at Disney guide

We stopped by Casey’s Corner to grab the new Headless Horseman Treat for $6.99. This is a pumpkin pie tart topped with whipped cheesecake, spiced caramel panna cotta, candied pecans, and marshmallow buttercream “flames”.

Headless Horseman Treat

If you consider yourself a pumpkin lover, a cheesecake lover, or both, this tart is worth seeking out. The pumpkin pie filling is smooth and mousse-like, and it holds its own against the whipped cheesecake layer rather than being overpowered by it — the two flavors stay well balanced from the first bite to the last. The pumpkin filling is also spiced with a light hand; rather than leaning hard into cinnamon the way so many fall desserts do, the spice level here feels intentional and restrained, letting the pumpkin flavor come through clearly.

Pumpkin fans will love!

The whipped cheesecake layer is the real standout for us. It’s silky smooth with just the right amount of tang, giving it that classic cream cheese cheesecake flavor without tasting artificial or overly sweet. Underneath it all, the pâte sucrée crust is soft, tender, and delicately crumbly — it breaks apart easily with each bite rather than fighting back, which is exactly what you want from a good tart shell.

Dig in!

The candied pecans add a welcome crunch and a toasty, spiced contrast to all that creaminess, though our one critique is a matter of proportion rather than flavor: we found ourselves wishing for a slightly more generous scattering of pecans across the top. For fans of nutty toppings, a touch more crunch would take this treat from great to perfect.

The back of the treat

There are a few other party treats you can grab while you’re at Casey’s Corner! It’s worth noting that you can Mobile Order here and that could save you some time if you order ahead.

Casey’s Corner Party Menu Items

You can also grab the Chipotle Barbecue Pork and Street Corn French Fries at Casey’s during the party. These are French fries topped with fire-roasted corn, queso fresco, jalapeño ranch, and cilantro for $8.49. These are classic Disney fries, but the toppings take them up a notch. You also get a good topping-per-fry ratio, and honestly, these could seriously be a meal.

These were good!

And, don’t forget the Chipotle Barbecue Pork and Street Corn Mini Corn Dogs for $13.49. These are mini corn dogs topped with fire-roasted corn, queso fresco, jalapeño ranch, and cilantro. We didn’t love these as much as the fries, but the flavors with the topping are delicious. The pork is tender, and the queso fresco is OH, so creamy (plus you get a lot — and you know we love the cheese). Both of these snacks have a bit of spice, but trust us, it’s not overwhelming. The topping is also available on hot dogs, too! The Chipotle Barbecue Pork and Street Corn Hot Dog for $15.49 is another option that comes with the same toppings as well!

mi Chipotle BBQ Pork Corn Dogs Nuggets

We’ll be bringing you everything you need to know about Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party at Magic Kingdom this year, so make sure you stay tuned to the Disney Food Blog for the latest Halloween news from Disney World and more!

EVERYTHING You Need To Know About Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party at Magic Kingdom

IT’S SPOOK-TACULAR!


Get ready for the spookiest season of the year at Disney World with our guide — Halloween at Disney World: DFB’s Spook-tacular Guide!

From the thrills of Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party to the enchanting resort decorations that’ll send shivers down your spine, our guide is packed with tips and tricks to help you squeeze every ounce of ghoulish fun out of your visit. Plus, we’ve got the inside scoop on all the limited-time-only bone-chilling activities happening across the parks!

Get the Halloween at Disney World: DFB’s Spook-tacular Guide to make your frightfully delightful adventure even more magical!

Are you heading to Mickey’s Not-So-Scary Halloween Party this year? Let us know in the comments below!

Important Disney Dates Simplified – Get a list of all of your important dates for your upcoming Disney vacation so you don’t miss a thing.